Jul 3, 2020 at 15:22 UTC Updated Jul 3, 2020 at 15:41 UTC
Russia’s Supreme Court (Credit: Shutterstock/E.O.) Russian Courts Can’t Agree on Whether Crypto Is Property
Russian courts are making conflicting rulings on whether bitcoin and other cryptocurrencies count as property.
In one new case, Saint Petersburg’s district court has refused to force bogus law enforcement officers to return cryptocurrencies extorted from a victim on the basis that digital assets are not legitimate assets.
According to the press office Telegram channel for the Saint Petersburg courts, the district court convicted two men for extorting money from an unnamed cryptocurrency OTC trader on June 30.
The criminals had pretended to be officers of Russia’s law enforcement and counter-terrorism agency, the Federal Security Service (FSB) – the successor of the KGB.
Threatening to beat and torture the victim, as well as faking that they’d opened a felony case against him, Petr Piron and Eugeny Prigozhin forced the victim to pay them 5 million rubles (over $70,000) in cash and transfer 99.7035 in bitcoin and some DigiByte and BitShares tokens to their digital wallets.The bitcoin alone is worth over $900,000 at current prices.
According to the court press release, the victim has been handed back the cash that was stolen.However, the court did not rule that the cryptocurrencies should also be transferred back.The court’s website confirms the convictions, although it does not provide the text of the ruling.
The press release, however, points out that, under the Russian Civil Code, cryptocurrencies have no legal status and therefore cannot be deemed property for the purpose of a criminal case.Plain wrong?
The decision is nothing more than a mistake, believes crypto-savvy lawyer and deputy head of the Chamber of Tax Consultants in Russia, Mikhail Uspenskiy.“The stance that cryptocurrency is some kind of a dummy and has no legal significance, is deeply flawed and erroneous,” Uspenskiy told CoinDesk.
He pointed out that, previously, the Russian courts have recognized crypto as a form of property.Uspenskiy cited the case of Ilya Tsarkov, who filed for bankruptcy in 2017 and was forced to reveal his crypto holdings so that they can be included in his estate for bankruptcy proceedings.
There have been also criminal cases in which the courts treated crypto assets like a form of property, such as when bitcoin was extorted during blackmail or fake banknotes exchanged for crypto, Uspenskiy said.
And in another case, after a Russian court refused to recognize crypto losses claimed by ICO investors who used an online investment platform called ICOadm.in, a Moscow court of appeals backed the original ruling, but did define cryptocurrency as “other kind of property.”
The appeals court further said that, under Russian law, crypto is not defined either as property, an asset, a money surrogate or information.
That may soon change.
In June, a package of draft bills was introduced in the country’s parliament, the State Duma, suggesting that cryptocurrencies should be treated as property.The bills would also, however, prohibit any operations with crypto using Russia-based infrastructure.
The initiative has been criticized by Russia’s Mininstry of Economic Development and Ministry of Justice, as well as by the crypto community advocates in the country.
Disclosure
The leader in blockchain news, CoinDesk is a media outlet that strives for the highest journalistic standards and abides by a strict set of editorial policies.CoinDesk is an independent operating subsidiary of Digital Currency Group, which invests in cryptocurrencies and blockchain startups.Share this: Bitcoin Price Eyes Quarterly Loss After Hitting 3.5-Month Low markets View Bitcoin has dropped more than 25 percent in the third quarter, neutralizing the bullish setup on the monthly chart.With the weekly and the three-day charts biased bearish, the cryptocurrency risks falling to $7,500 in the short-term.A violation there would expose the next major support, currently at $7,070.
A corrective bounce may… Bitcoin Closes on First February Price Loss Since 2014 Feb 28, 2020 at 11:34 UTCBitcoin is close to ending February on a negative note for the first time in six years.The biggest cryptocurrency by market value is currently trading at $8,625, representing a 7.5 percent drop from the opening price of $9,339 seen on Feb.
1, according to Bitstamp data.The global average price,… Ohio Lawmakers Pitch Their State As a Future Hub for Blockchain NEWS Aug 24, 2018 at 13:15 UTC Lawmakers in the U.S.state of Ohio say they are interested in blockchain – but they’re still figuring out how to put that enthusiasm into action.At a press conference on Aug.23, Ohio House of Representatives Speaker Ryan Smith convened a group that included lawmakers, business owners… Securitize Issues Crypto Token Representing Newsletter Business news Securitize, a firm that enables the issuance and management digital securities, announced its tenth on-chain digital asset.The Curzio Equity Owners’s (CEO) token represents an equity stake in the financial publishing analytics firm Curzio Research’s newsletter business.The token presents a path to invest in a “scalable, high-margin industry that is normally difficult for… Hold-It-Yourself Crypto Exchange LGO to Roll Out Hardware Wallet in Q2 news LGO Markets, a new bitcoin exchange for institutional traders, has revealed more details about its unorthodox approach to custody, including a forthcoming optional hardware wallet.Launched in March, New York-based LGO bills itself as a one-of-a-kind exchange that will allow clients to control their coins instead of putting them in the exchange’s wallet.
The idea… Ethereum Upgrades as Hard Forks Activate on Blockchain news Two long-anticipated upgrades appear to have officially activated on the ethereum blockchain, the world’s second-largest by market value, without incident.At 19:57 (UTC), the sixth and seventh system-wide upgrades to the software, dubbed Constantinople and St.Petersburg, respectively, rolled out on the main network at block number 7,280,000.As seen on blockchain monitoring website Fork Monitor, there… PBoC-Backed Blockchain Trade Finance Platform Enters Test Phase A blockchain trade finance platform spearheaded by China’s central bank has entered the testing phase ahead of an official roll-out.
According to a report from 21st Century Business Herald on Tuesday, the first phase of the so-called Bay Area Trade Finance Blockchain Platform is already deployed across financial institutions in the southern city of Shenzhen and is… BitMEX Trading Engine Goes Offline, Company ‘Investigating’ May 19, 2020 at 12:58 UTCUpdated May 19, 2020 at 13:17 UTCArthur Hayes, CEO of BitMEX, at CoinDesk Consensus 2018 (Credit: ConiDesk archives)BitMEX Trading Engine Goes Offline, Company ‘Investigating’[UPDATED 13:06 UTC] The trading engine for BitMEX, formerly the largest bitcoin derivatives exchange measured by open interest, went down on Tuesday at 12:13 UTC, according to… How Decentralized Tech Can End the Privacy Crisis in 2020 Dec 19, 2019 at 17:00 UTCHow Decentralized Tech Can End the Privacy Crisis in 2020This post is part of CoinDesk’s 2019 Year in Review, a collection of 100 op-eds, interviews and takes on the state of blockchain and the world.Tor Bair is the Head of Growth for Enigma, an open-source, decentralized protocol for secure… Leave a Reply You must be logged in to post a comment.Search.
