The idea that sterling has effectively become an emerging-market currency has become something of a common refrain in the four years since the Brexit vote.
Bloomberg’s Sid Verma asked whether the pound was the “new Mexican peso” as early as October 2016, and the idea that it should be treated as an EM currency has been repeated many times since then.In September last year, then Bank of England Governor Mark Carney became the most high-profile person to join this gloomy chorus, pointing out that sterling volatility was at “emerging market levels”, and that the currency had “ decoupled ” from its peers.
On Wednesday, it was the turn of a Bank of America analyst named Kamal Sharma, who said movements in the exchange rate had become “neurotic at best, unfathomable at worst” (we’re not quite sure what that means either), and that the pound was now an emerging market currency in all but name.Apparently Brexit had turned the pound into a mirror of the “small and shrinking” UK economy.
So is there any truth to this? We’d argue no.
For a start, for sterling to really be an emerging market currency, wouldn’t Britain have to be an emerging market? It seems an odd designation for the fifth- or sixth-biggest economy in the world, where income-per-capita is above $45,000 (almost four times above the threshold the World Bank sets to demarcate a “high-income country”).
Ironically enough, those that argue that sterling is an “EM currency” are surely using very much the wrong term here.If the country is wilting away, surely “emerging” is the wrong word? Wouldn’t shrivelling be better? Drooping? Submerging? A wilting market currency, perhaps? “Emerging” suggests that the country’s economy is growing.
Second, just because implied volatility — a measure of the market’s expectations for future gyrations in the exchange rate — is high, why should that suggest the pound is an EM currency? Clearly Brexit has been destabilising and has left the future unclear, and we all know that the one thing markets can’t stand is uncertainty, so it doesn’t seem very surprising that volatility — both actual and implied — is raised.Once some political stability has been reached, it seems likely that volatility will fall too.
Third, just because there is now less liquidity in the pound than some of its major peers like the dollar or euro, that again does not mean it is an EM currency.There’s a difference between no longer being in the hallowed “G5” group of currencies — which it is not at all clear the pound has fallen out of permanently either — and being an emerging market currency.The Swedish krona isn’t particularly liquid, but it’s not considered EM.
We called up Stephen Jen, CEO of Eurizon SLJ, a hedge fund that specialises in emerging markets, to get his thoughts on the matter.
He was pretty emphatic about the fact that sterling was very much not an EM currency in any way, shape or form, telling us (emphasis ours):
When you think of the uses of money — you have store of value, unit of account, medium of exchange — on all three measures it’s very difficult to argue that sterling is not one of the prime, prime, currencies in the world.It’s the number three reserve currency in the world, based on the global data, and it takes a lot of soft power for a currency to achieve that status.If you look at all the currencies that have a reserve status, they are issued by countries that have a lot of soft power.It’s not just economic might — look at India and China, their currencies are nowhere on the list.
It’s difficult to lose that soft power, which would include things like culture, rule of law, if it’s perceived to be fair, if it operates without a lot of intervention or controls from the government, no surprises, and if it’s governed by English law, which is well understood by the markets and the world — intangible and difficult-to-quantify practices of a country.All of these underpin the support for a currency such as sterling, and it’s very difficult to supplant such a status.In for a penny, in for a pound
We also called up Savvas Savouri, chief economist at Toscafund Asset Management, another hedge fund, to get his take.He told us the idea was nonsense, and that anyway he didn’t necessarily feel that calling sterling an EM currency was pejorative, given that could just be interpreted as meaning that it was grossly undervalued.
He told us (our emphasis, again):
This time next year the pound will be materially stronger , in all dimensions.One thing I’ve always remained steadfast on is that there will be an eleventh hour deal to avoid a no-deal Brexit… and the pound will then gap up — to 1.3 against the euro and 1.6 against the dollar.That’s just using back-of-the envelope, econ 101 calculations.
Another characteristic of emerging markets (that is very much lacking in Britain’s case) is that their businesses and governments often borrow in foreign currencies — usually the dollar or the euro — due to the lower cost of borrowing associated with assets denominated in leading currencies.
If you’re located in the UK, it’s difficult to see why you’d bother to do that, given that the government’s cost of borrowing for five years is near record lows of -0.06 per cent hit on Thursday, and the cost of borrowing for ten years remains ultra low at around 0.15 per cent as of Friday morning.
It’s also worth remembering that, as Jen points out, the UK has global reserve currency status, making up 5 per cent of official sector reserves, according to IMF data.That’s more than the Swiss Franc, Australian dollar and Canadian dollar combined.
The Fund’s figures also show that the proportion of claims in sterling have actually risen since the vote in the middle of 2016.
Why does this matter? Because it lessens the risk that the cost of borrowing for the government will rise substantially any time soon.
All this is not to say that the pound’s status hasn’t been significantly affected by Brexit; clearly it has been, at least temporarily.But the UK is still one of the world’s biggest and most influential economies, with leading universities, the English language, and high-quality cultural and manufacturing exports.
Let’s not get carried away; the Great British Peso will live to see another day.
Related links: Is this the nuttiest risk factor of all time? The tech start-up that wants to “validate” the female orgasm It’s a great time for conspiracy theories to thrive Let’s call Trump out, but let’s get our facts straight too Today, in efficient markets We can’t blame all the indirect health damage on the lockdown Weirdly, blockchain can’t help combat coronavirus Leading ‘UK’ start-ups want a handout too China’s PMI print doesn’t mean much Let’s flatten the coronavirus confusion curve NMC Health: presented without comment When “commission-free trading” isn’t (really) free Michael Milken: financial innovator Oh no, the death-techers are coming Bitcoin’s “halvening” won’t boost its price CEO of JPM, recipient of $bns in state aid, bashes socialism Trump just made a joke about negative rates The Witcher is not a freelancer The ITV M&A fantasy Blockchain, all over your face Baillie Gifford: pot kettle black Is Facebook’s status as the bête noire of political advertising justified? The Eurosystem might have a fatal flaw.But it’s not this Venture capital for the ‘forgotten’ The troublesome Trump inside trading claim The US economy is not recession-proof Hedge fund bro gonna hedge fund bro What do women want? Some crypto flavoured mansplaining, apparently.The Fed’s wishful thinking on inflation Dalio and Diddy: when genius collides State-backed crypto is a contradiction Rejoice! Venture capital wants to pay for your holiday Are electric vehicles more damaging than diesel? The £3bn hole in the Tory manifesto ArtGo loses its marbles Are banks really magic money trees? Will Lagarde’s sneaky tweet change much? Can we all calm down about Apple Card’s “gender bias” UBS’ billionaire boondoggle When fast fashion jumps on the eco-wagon GenX will set central banks’ climate response The stablecoin anathema Masters of the universe, don’t be scared of Elizabeth Warren Missing: the GE short report The average lifespan of a fiat currency isn’t 27 years Lord King: Brexit is no big deal No inflation? Tell that to my landlord Today, in fintech marketing YouGov’s “blockchain-based” sell-your-own data platform makes no sense (*update) Presented without comment Ride-sharing apps can’t save the planet (obv) The WeWork bull case No deal Brexit is not a hedge fund conspiracy Europe’s digital infrastructure issue Let’s give a helping hand to Andrew Yang Anatomy of a malware scam ARK Invest’s Tesla model gathers dust A delirious defence of Uber WeLiquid: Adam Neumann pockets $700m Yesterday, in efficient markets The warm fuzzy feeling of indirectly owning Tencent The best of Morgan Stanley’s Adam Jonas Apple/Tesla: M&A and heartbreak Did Beyonce make $300m from Uber’s IPO? Bitcoin is the 10-year Treasury of our time High resolution music is a solution looking for a problem Amazon is furious about this negative review Missing: $500bn of American savings Blockchain for Brexit: a wonderfully terrible idea The Bank of Hodlers [sic] (sigh) Behind the curtain at China Ding Yi Feng An answer to Mark Cuban’s question Crumbs! It’s CRYPTO: the movie! National Beverage Corp loses its fizz, and its mind Amazon won’t spin-off Amazon Web Services Mensch! Dan McCrum is innocent, ok? Europe’s $1 trillion tax gap Why online propaganda mobs are an investment red flag Davos has produced an amazing new guide on precisely how not to think about risk When the public relations industry does PR for itself Who wants to be crippled by student debt? The bitcoin price is wrong The warm fuzzy feeling of Goldman debt “Cryptoassets” are crashing again.Is it time to start calling them cryptoliabilities instead? Puff the tragic cryptowagon smokes out the Mumsnet demographic Don’t write off the public sector Initiative Q: an elementary pyramid scheme with grandiose ideas [Update] Moral investments aren’t outperforming No one is killing it in crypto (not even Woz) Too smooth: the red flag at Patisserie Valerie which was missed No, the housing crisis will not be solved by building more homes Sorry Civil, ‘crypto-economics’ and ‘constitutions’ won’t save journalism ‘Short-termism’ isn’t a thing, say Fed economists Coinbase wants to be “too big to fail”, lol Regulation and innovation don’t have to be enemies Retailers get so lonely around the holidays Folli Follie: $1bn of fake sales, and what to learn from the debacle The new green evangelism Tilray, how low can it go? The ICO behind the tragic Everest stunt is now “airdropping” tokens from rockets Beware the Hindenburg Omen? The broken conversation about financial regulation The improbably profitable, loss-making Blue Prism The EM rout is not made in America Wages and growth and honestly we just give up Britain’s first blockchain-enabled co-working space isn’t blockchain-enabled There is a FIRE that never goes out The WeWork Garden of Eden IQE: lumpy ‘Apple’ sauce at the pricey Cardiff chip shop There’s only so much a central bank can do alone Eight questions every first-time buyer should ask MiFID II: not all doom and gloom Tesla: getting to Q3 profitability Turkey contagion fears are overblown [Update] The chance of an inflation shock may be higher than you think Sorry Tim, the humanity is not being drained out of music Digital crop circles What could go wrong here? Sirius Minerals: money for a hole in the ground The Bank of England has a strange idea of what QE achieved One for the ladies… ‘Of course, many ridiculous papers appeared’ Is a change goin’ to come? The capacity’s not there yet (and probably never will be) Musk and Tesla are not inseparable Libraries, from Carnegie to Bezos Crypto & government: from anarchy to amity in the USA ‘I’m sorry Dave, I’m afraid I cannot sanction this Series B round’ RBC, through the FANG barrier Self-help to buy CFA: Chartered crypto analysts — updated The Netflix dilemma — updated Fujitsu’s new blockchain offering: really cheap or really expensive? Nothing But the Shirt on Your Back Universities of Britain: cosying up to crypto is a bad look How to make a living in the cult of meritocracy Spotify: Drake-oil salesmen Sports are not markets, predictions ain’t investment Spot the difference, Steinhoff edition Larry Robbins, a cautionary tale The node to serfdom Carney is down with the crypto kids Samsonite: inventory, excess baggage, and unresolved questions It might be a long wait for “the equivalent alternative to ICOs” Don’t blame it on the sunshine In corporate America, brands develop you One in ten dollars of US housing were anonymous Should AT&T worry more about its debt? Who cares if Elon is incinerating capital? Let’s not try make ‘crypto chicks’ a thing Tokens all the way down Eight-dimensional chess with Elon Musk A lopsided trade is a good trade, Italian inflation edition How to buy Italian fire insurance Atlas bugged Crypto’s most devout believers are suffering a crisis of faith Plus500: past performance is no guide to the future Noble rot in a shrinking Harbour In defence of ticket touts Please don’t tell individual investors to buy leveraged loans RIB Software: the unicorn rainy-day fund Retail is not dead Did Soros really give Tesla a “vote of confidence”? At a crypto conference in New York, it feels like 2017 all over again Egregious expectations – Intelsat edition Bitcoin cash is expanding into the void Stop getting The Flintstones wrong Bond investors do not care if Argentina is solvent in 100 years Ubiquiti Networks: of cash and borrowed time “We’re very disappointed in you, Spotify” ‘Sex redistribution’ and the means of reproduction Tesla probably needs to raise capital this year No entitlement crisis in America Free cash flow to whom? Hey crypto bros! Journalism ≠ advertising Human capital and the jobs guarantee This is a tech bubble, when’s the crash? The magic of adjustments: ebitla-dee-da FUD, inglorious FUD A complex analysis reaches same conclusion as simple one: hedge funds suck The jobs guarantee and human-capital “nationalisation” These hedge fund numbers can’t be right The Vomiting Camel has escaped from Bitcoin zoo Lies, damn lies, and charticles The world doesn’t need more Elon Musks No, Facebook should not become a nonprofit Sell all crypto and abandon all blockchain Immutable ledgers meet European data protection Amazon is not a bubble Japan’s economic miracle Have you ever meta crypto joke you didn’t like? Delaware should change its rules to let the light in Who needs the labels anyway? Baby Boomers want your family to finance a larger share of their retirement No, America would not benefit from authoritarian central planning No one needs to buy Tesla How to win a debate in the cult of meritocracy Steinhoff International and the case of Pepkor Global Sourcing Sorry Jack, Bitcoin will not become the global currency The “academic’s cryptocurrency” is an elegant waste of time Cigarettes are the vice America needs Well that’s one reason to buy yen… Musicians, don’t just blame the labels for your lack of dough Giving stock away to staff doesn’t absolve share buybacks A penny for Macpherson’s thoughts on the nominal anchor Monopoly and its discontents America is not the least protectionist country in the world This is nuts, when does Netflix crash? No Bloomberg, the world’s richest people did not lose $114bn… Someone is wrong on the internet, government employee pensions and passive investing edition Someone is wrong on the internet, possibly fragile Someone is wrong on the internet, consumer financial regulation edition Someone is wrong on the internet: tontine tokens [Update] Someone is wrong on the internet, road economics edition Someone is wrong on the internet, wages and the stock market edition Copyright The Financial Times Limited 2020.
All rights reserved.
You may share using our article tools.Please don’t cut articles from FT.com and redistribute by email or post to the web.
For the latest news and updates, follow us on Google News .Also, if you like our efforts, consider sharing this story with your friends, this will encourage us to bring more exciting updates for you..